| 1974 |
27-13 |
Waugh-Wright-Beavers |
| 1975 |
22-16 |
Waugh-Wright-Beavers |
| 1976 |
22-12 |
Waugh-Wright-Beavers |
| 1977 |
35-5 |
Beavers-England |
| 1978 |
24-10 |
Beavers-England |
| 1979 |
35-9 |
Beavers-Bozman |
| 1980 |
34-10 |
Beavers-Bozman |
| 1981 |
30-11 |
Beavers-S.Boch |
| 1982 |
35-11 |
Beavers-C.Boch |
| 1983 |
32-15 |
Beavers-Griggs-Poling |
| 1984 |
33-25 |
Beavers-Griggs-VanScoy |
| 1985 |
33-13 |
Beavers-Hatem-Reynolds |
| 1986 |
29-20 |
Beavers-VanScoy |
| 1987 |
45-14 |
Beavers-Dillon-Poling |
| 1988 |
41-22 |
Beavers-Dillon-Hoppe |
| 1989 |
25-15 |
Beavers-Dillon-Hoppe-Swackhammer |
| 1990 |
15-22 |
Beavers-Dillon-Hoppe-Swackhammer |
| 1991 |
39-17 |
Beavers-Griggs-Hoppe-Maddux |
| 1992 |
39-13 |
Beavers-Griggs-Maddux |
| 1993 |
22-26 |
Beavers-Griggs-Wickham-Beavers |
| 1994 |
12-28 |
Beavers-Griggs-Beavers |
| 1995 |
32-26 |
Beavers-Griggs-Anderson |
| 1996 |
40-20 |
Beavers-Griggs-Bozman |
| 1997 |
39-15 |
Beavers-Griggs-Bozman |
| 1998 |
40-16 |
Beavers-Bozman-Burke-Curry |
| 1999 |
39-15 |
Bozman-Curry-Smeltzer-Bozman |
| 2000 |
40-11 |
Bozman-Curry-Smeltzer-Bozman |
| 2001 |
24-22 |
Rice-Bozman-Roth |
| 2002 |
35-18 |
Rice-Bozman-Beavers-Destadio |
| 2003 |
23-18 |
Rice-Bozman-Destadio |
| 2004 |
23-27 |
Burke-Wickham-Beavers-Anderson |
| 2005 |
31-21 |
Burke-Wickham-Beavers-Anderson |
| 2006 |
31-15 |
Burke-Beavers-Anderson-Welch |
| 2007 |
28-17 |
Burke-Beavers-Welch |
| 2008 |
33-14 |
Burke-Beavers-Welch |
| 2009 |
31-10 |
Burke-Beavers |
| 2010 |
25-14 |
Burke-Beavers |
| 2011 |
15-24 |
Burke-Beavers |
| 2012 |
35-21 |
Beavers-Bradley |
| 2013 |
15-31 |
Beavers-Welch |
| 2014 |
12-26 |
Beavers-Welch |
| 2015 |
11-25 |
Beavers-McElwee-Lands |
| 2016 |
14-34 |
Beavers-Lands-Mathias |
| 2017 |
28-17 |
Beavers-Rowland-Slykerman-Hyme |
| 2018 |
23-14 |
Beavers-Rowland-Slykerman-Sisson |
| 2019 |
30-22 |
Rowland-Slykerman-Sisson |
| 2020 |
30-18 |
Rowland-Slykerman-Hyme-Sisson |
| 2021 |
22-19 |
Rowland-Slykerman-Hyme-Sisson |
| 2022 |
26-13 |
Rowland-Slykerman-Wolfe-Sisson |
| 2023 |
28-8 |
Rowland-Slykerman-Rowland-Sisson |